In a previous post titled ADAC and VLAN Configurations I described some issues we were having with some of our switches where VLAN memberships were mysteriously changing. We suspected ADAC and we were right on with our suspicions.
We performed some exhaustive testing with ADAC over the past few weeks and can confirm, as Roberto alluded too, that ADAC will dynamically reconfigure any switch port that has ADAC enabled to the VLAN membership and PVID setting that was set when ADAC was first enabled on the switch port. In our tests we configured an edge port as a member of VLAN 10 and then enabled ADAC on that port. We then added the edge port to VLAN 11, removing it from VLAN 10. When the port went into an oper-down state ADAC added the edge port back to VLAN 10 and removed it from VLAN 11. We confirmed the same behavior with respect to the PVID changing.
In short if you need to make a VLAN membership or PVID change to an ADAC enabled port you MUST disable ADAC on the port before making the change and then re-enable ADAC when you have completed your change. As a side note any Nortel IP phone that is connected to the port will most likely timeout and reboot itself when you disable ADAC.
While I don’t necessarily disagree with the behavior it would be nice for either the CLI of Device Manager to alert someone if they tried to change the VLAN membership of a port that had ADAC enabled. (hint hint Nortel)
Cheers!
In short Nortel is now advising that you MUST have unique VRRP IDs. Nortel recommends as best practice that you use the VLAN ID but that can be problematic since valid values for the VLAN ID are between 1..4096 and valid values for the VRRP ID are between 1..512. In my case the VLAN IDs were between 1 and 200 so I was able to match them up.
Nortel has released a Technical Configuration Guide designed to assist technical users configuring Nortel IP Phones connected to Cisco switches. The document makes specific references to the Cisco 3750 switch but the commands will apply to any Cisco switch that supports that specific feature.